Question:
Should United States give African Americans an apology gor slavery?
Patricia G
2008-04-21 09:52:07 UTC
Should United States give African Americans an apology gor slavery?
38 answers:
2008-04-21 09:56:09 UTC
Well, it certainly wouldn't hurt. We were terribly wrong after all!! :@)
truean1
2008-04-21 10:32:21 UTC
No,



For all the reasons listed by the people above.....



Why should the people of the U.S. be held liable for an offense they were not alive to give to those who are not alive to be offended?



Also, in all actuality, the U.S. already did something far greater than words: the Civil War. What good do you think words are? They fade away after you speak them. The country you are speaking off tore itself apart in a bloody, drawn out war over the issue of slavery. I am fully aware of the "state's rights" justification of the civil war. This is a lie and I recognize it as such. The "state's rights" was the right to determine if that state could hold slaves or not.... Hence fighting over slavery or the right to have slaves is the same thing....



The best part is that the U.S. conducted the civil war on its own: hundreds of years before anyone could have forced it to do so. Lots of cultures had (and some still have) slaves. The U.S. was the only place to do something about it and end it.

This was a conflict that tore families apart and a lot of white men died so that black ones wouldn't be slaves, because they thought it was wrong.
2008-04-21 10:00:10 UTC
No the United states is a country and not people ( who would be the ones to apologize??)!!



Also the people who first started slavery is dead and gone, so they would have to be the ones the apology came from.



Yes, slavery happened and it was wrong, but we have learned from it and we should all move on. Instead of being stuck in the past and having hatred against one another!



I am black and I have never experiened slavery, neither has my mother, or her mother or her mother. Some people just like to stir up unnecessary drama instead of dealing with their real problem. I recognize that slavery was wrong, along with the holocaust, and the rwandan genocide and every other atrocity that occurred, but I am not dwelling on it.
Variable 46
2008-04-21 10:09:08 UTC
The U.S. government took four years out of my father's life and made him fight in WWII. He came back a changed person, heavy drinker. It affected lives all around him for generations. Viet-Nam vets came back, abused and unsupported. Gulf War vets suffer a number of unexplained traumas. Americans of Japanese descent were ordered out of their homes in the 1940s. The government conducted open-air A-bomb tests in Nevada and didn't warn locals about the radiation. The government got us into a hopeless war in Iraq and thousands have been killed or maimed. The IRS took too much money out of my paycheck last year. Tens of thousands of soldiers were killed in the Civil War to preserve the Union, which by the way also ended slavery; do their descendents deserve an apology too? The list of victims is endless, if you subscribe to a victim mentality.



Does the government owe apologies for all of that? For any of it? Yes. All of it involves a certain element of injustice. Will the government ever actually apologise for any of it? Sure, but not out of any genuine remorse; but instead only when it is politically expedient for certain parties to do so. And will that apology, if and when it comes, actually do any meaningful, day-to-day good in your life? Not one little bit. So why waste time moaning about it?



And by the way, while thinking of all the things that government has done that were unjust and cruel; also give a thought to all the good and just things the government has done was well.
Amy
2008-04-21 09:58:43 UTC
Well, I honestly don't see how several generations removed can effectively apologize to several generations removed. The people apologizing were not the ones who did the atrocity, and the people being apologized too are not the ones who it was done to. The government should recognize it, recognize that it was a horrible thing that never should have happened. But I don't know what the point of an aplogy would be.
Toni
2008-04-21 10:03:42 UTC
No. Short and simple. We can not apologize on behalf of our ancestors, just because we believe that it was wrong, does not mean that our ancestors did. It would not be a true apology. None of the people alive today were involved in the slavery of the African Americans 400 years ago. :| If you are going to apologize to the black people, you better apologize to my people, the mexicans, and the indians for stealing our land. Thats about all I have to say.
2008-04-22 09:03:26 UTC
that would be a huge NO , their own people traded them into slavery for trinkets now really whom should apologize ? and even after being traded into slavery many of them had a much better life here in the states than than could have hoped for otherwise . today they have the right to vote and many programs are weigted for the black race . the black race should be thanking us that they was given the oppurtunity to live here in the usa .
kja63
2008-04-21 09:57:47 UTC
Why??



The native Africans sold their own people into slavery, but that ended over 100 years ago. People living in the USA today have never known slavery. Nor have their parents. Nor have their grandparents. Nor have their great-grandparents.



Enough is enough. Otherwise, I demand an apology from all descendants of ancient Rome for the persecution of Christians.
?
2008-04-21 10:59:47 UTC
Since the U.S. banned slavery 150 years ago but there is still an active slave trade in Africa, it's hard to see why they should. Any apologies nowadays should could from people practicing slavery within our borders in defiance of U.S. law, not from people who had nothing to do with it.
Rosa
2008-04-21 09:59:47 UTC
How about lets leave the past in the past? Slavery is an old issue, we have bigger concerns in Africa and all the other different parts of the country. If the US have to apologize to everyone they screwed, then they will have a long list of names.



How about the Japanese that the US put in concentration camps during the 40s?



The Native Americans they slaughtered?



The South American countries they rob from?
Rob
2008-04-21 10:00:49 UTC
I thought black history month was a partial apology. Personally, I am sorry African Americans were enslaved.
HAPA CHIC
2008-04-21 10:29:42 UTC
well I am not American but I saw many on here compaling when Austrailia apologized to the aboriginals there and stated how racists they were.....I did not see the difference between the Austrialians and what occured in America with the blacks their slavery and segregation.

They apologized to the Japanese maybe its time to apologize and move on with a good future between everyone
2008-04-21 10:18:55 UTC
The American people did. America's apology was the Civil War. Ten's of thousands of men died to free the slaves. Giving ones life for a cause is the best apology one can give.
BrandonLA- think blue
2008-04-21 10:01:10 UTC
No, because it's just bringing up the past.



If they apologize to just african american... i think they're forgetting about Native Americans and Asians WWII.
?
2016-11-08 10:38:35 UTC
there is probably no sincere and equitable thank you to distribute reparations and make certain who will pay what. some factors to contemplate: a million. could the decendants of the thousands of Union infantrymen who died in the Civil warfare be expempt from making money? 2. could all those whose ancestors got here to this u . s . a . after the tip of slavery be exempt. 3. could human beings of blended race might desire to make money as properly as obtain some. How could that be performed. 4. could people who've gained multiple kinds of government advantages have a definite element deducted from their reparation money? 5. could companies in the North that exploited immigrant hard artwork be held as in charge as planters in the South? the former team paid wages yet did no longer take any accountability for his or her workers. The latter team did no longer pay wages, profited from slave hard artwork, yet took accountability for his or her workers from cradle to grave. the two structures had their inequities. How do you identify which workers are owed extra? The checklist of questions might desire to bypass on and on. isn't there some thank you to settle the debts in techniques that don't pit one team of human beings against yet another? they may be argued advert infinitem, yet there are actually not basic solutions. maybe we would desire to continually stumble on a thank you to settle the depts of yet another technology in a fashion that works for each individual. case in point, all and sundry's toddlers deserve stable educations, equivalent oportunities and the mutual appreciate of all different human beings. If all of us artwork in direction of those objectives, inspite of the circumstances of our ancestors, in time, we would desire to stumble on basic techniques to make issues extra efficient, if no longer precisely even.
2008-04-21 09:56:33 UTC
No! It's ridiculous. Slavery was terrible and wrong but it was hundreds of years ago in the nation's past. Why not make the Italians apologise to the Jews for sending them into Diaspora thousands of years ago? You can't apologise for everything in the past; what's far more important is focusing on maintaining a society without discrimination, prejudice and one where everyone is considered truly equal.
2008-04-21 11:34:08 UTC
honey



to be frank, apologies are necessary for nearly all nationalities, which this country was built on. The government would do, because just as there were British, English, French, Spanish, who enslaved Africans, Hatians, Chinese, Italians, Spanish, etc, were also treated wrong, think of the railroads, which were set up primarily by Chinese, Africans, and Native Americans.



And to mention Native Americans, this is not the land belonging to any of us, except them, and look what happened to them. They are damn near extinct. When you see parades, most of those people you see arent even Indian, they are either inter-racial, or Mexican, or Hispanic, all together.



Yes slavery was a business, because Africans traded Africans- thats fact, also with other countries/continents, as well as Europeans, but the British has treated African worse- far more worse then any nationality, just because they could, and more African has lost their lives, than any other nationality, including jews. We don't know how many were killed, because they were not fully truthfull with "the cargo", and in addition to that so many of them were "lost at sea", and there were hundreds of voyages using trade ships, from Africa to many countries, not just here.

So when you speak of an appology, its a start, no money could ever replace whats been done, but for someone to open their bloody mouth, and admitt of wrong doing, lifts alot of possible resentment, or angry feelings,



I mean where do you want to start, if these were your anscestors how would you feel, to not be counted for by birth, to be called cargo, to carry the last name of someone who owned you, or had no blood relation to you? how would you feel, knowing if you bore a child, that child would not be considered a man, or a woman......but property?



there's a sh**load of facts so where should i start?



and these things were'nt just because some white dude with an accent said so. it was law.

From that we(Africans, African Americans, Malattos Moors Ni***s, ******, what ever you want to call us could not get an education, could not vote, could not get jobs, could not own anything, we didn't even own our children, or ourselves, and you question an apology.

Can you imagine being beaten close to death, just to be scared into subission to work the rest of your life?

Can you imagine you woman(cause you couldn't marry) being given to a white master for his pleasures?, or to populate his plantation?, or given to any slave for breeding purposes?

Can you imagine seeing your woman, or children being whipped, because they tried to run away?



These are just very few of the many things which went on during slavery, may i add, the state i reside, Maryland, has been known as a Lynching State, the area is called Eastern Shore, Maryland, have you heard of this? This is one of many places.



Want more? Some states riddled throughout the south, have until this day, auctioning posts which are still standing, and our government has said nothing as far as having it removed, and then some look at it as a sad reminder.

Just as many of us carry European last names, no longer speak our official languages, or more, were are still carrying the sir name of our ancestors slave masters(most of us).

what more do you need?

and i am not venting on you, i am just letting some who are saying no see what many of us have gone through......yes i say us, because our society have until this day labeled us as a statistic, labeled us for failure before we have even been conceived.

Those events which took place still stand in some form, do you understand divide and concquer? this phrase/strategy was found by a slave master named Willie Lynch, hence the term lynching.



Where this person( to control his slaves) would set up all kinds of conditions to force the slave into submission.

Separating the darker slave from the lighter on, the women from the men, the house slave from the field slave, beat the slaves senseless, but not killing them, and in many cases, form all kinds of mental brain-washing to force slaves to believe which ever he wanted them to believe.......that exisits today. in so many forms, like prison, like cults, even religious ones........honey, i could go on, and there's so many, infact too many factors i am missing, and i care not to go into right now, because its so saddening, but this is something for those of you to think about.



thank you for your time, and i didn't mean for the term paper, but its simply not a yes or no answer.



honeychild.
Mister G
2008-04-21 09:58:08 UTC
Yes. The devastating effects of segregation and racism that have resulted from slavery are still taking their toll today on black and inner city communities.



The UK apologized years ago, grow up American and swallow your pride.



BTW, black people legally have the vote, but unlike votes for women we still have not written that into our constitution. The president signed and renewed the order that was put forth decades ago, but their is nothing in our constitution that states people of color have the right to vote. Thats screwed up.
2008-04-21 11:45:53 UTC
No. There are no slaves still alive today. Since no one alive today was held slave by the US government, there is no reason to apologize. All those involved are dead and gone.
trspass4
2008-04-21 09:57:54 UTC
lol most of us where not alive during slavery. if any people need an apology lets talk native indians tribes or how about my people the jews.
2008-04-21 10:00:48 UTC
one race can't just apologize to another race, it just doesn't make any sense. I am appalled by what other people's ancestors have done, but it's not my fault because I'm white.
2008-04-21 09:56:06 UTC
huh. Neither I nor anyone I know was ever involved in slavery. My dad and granddad were not either.



You seem to be fixated on race. That is not a good thing for you to do. Go out and leanr about your neighbor.



Life is good. Live in the present. The past is gone.
2008-04-21 09:55:18 UTC
I know that we can apologize on behalf of our ancestors, but we also need to apologize to the native americans as well.
arklatexrat
2008-04-21 09:58:29 UTC
No, the descendants of slaves should be thanking the US for getting them out of the disease-infested poverty hole that is the country of Africa. Can they honestly say that in the long run they are not better off to be here in the US?



Read the story of Joseph & Moses in Egypt from Genesis and Exodus in the Bible. The US is paying for the slave trade just as Egypt did back then--the Jews rose up under slavery to become a mighty nation. You could say it was either because of the period of bondage or in spite of it, but either way it was brought about.



God works things out according to His plan for a reason--the blacks should acknowledge that and thank Him for His provision in getting them to place for better opportunity.



Or, if they are that dissatisfied, I suppose they could always go back to their homeland.
if you ask-listen for the answer
2008-04-21 09:56:13 UTC
An apology, yes...reparations, no! I am black, but I didn't have to suffer through slavery so I don't feel like I deserve any money for what my distant relatives had to go through.
Lush
2008-04-21 09:57:55 UTC
No. Why should America do that?



If anything, they (A.A.) should apologize to America. Case closed. Amen.
2008-04-21 09:56:47 UTC
Only if they apoligize to the mexicans and indians for taking their land



wich i know it wont happen
Erica s
2008-04-21 12:25:26 UTC
Only if there is anyone still alive from that era. I don't know of anyone.
Maus
2008-04-21 12:05:50 UTC
Like in what form, verbal? I'm all for it then.
2008-04-21 09:58:10 UTC
Honestly, an apology is not worth it. Something more sincere would be better.
2008-04-21 09:55:22 UTC
Hell NO!!!!!!! Why should they its not the US government enslaved them personally. Forget that. It happened 150 years ago get over it.
Paulfius
2008-04-21 09:58:29 UTC
No way! We needed help, and they helped us!
LOJunkie
2008-04-21 09:54:35 UTC
Short answer - yes
2008-04-21 09:55:17 UTC
I feel I deserve an apology.
thejoker8301
2008-04-21 09:58:29 UTC
no
pura_rosa
2008-04-21 09:54:28 UTC
YEs, and it's long overdue
2008-04-21 09:54:27 UTC
probably not
2008-04-21 09:54:28 UTC
Nah ...............................


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...